Ssh Official in Oahu
SSH INVESTIGATES: Why Katherine Kealoha is leaving prison In 2020 a federal judge sentenced Honolulu's former deputy prosecutor Katherine Kealoha to 13 years. On Nov. 20, 2026 she leaves prison for a halfway house. No judge ordered it, and no court granted her anything. Here is how that happens. PART ONE: THE FAMILY MONEY Kealoha took her uncle Gerard Puana's savings to invest and never returned more than $70,000. She steered her grandmother, Florence Puana, then 89, into a reverse mortgage of more than $513,000. More than $148,000 went in about seven months: Mercedes and Maserati car payments, Elton John tickets, a Disneyland trip and a $23,976 brunch celebrating her husband Louis Kealoha's swearing-in as police chief. In March 2013 her uncle and grandmother sued her. PART TWO: THE MAILBOX Around 11:30 p.m. on June 21, 2013, video at the Kealohas' Kahala home showed a man taking their mailbox. Eight days later police arrested Gerard Puana. A federal jury later found the mailbox was set up to be stolen, the video was edited, Gerard was falsely identified, reports were falsified, evidence was destroyed, and investigators, a grand jury and a federal court were lied to. Trial evidence showed about 30 officers from the chief's Criminal Intelligence Unit were assigned to watch Gerard around the clock. PART THREE: THE MISTRIAL On Dec. 4, 2014, at Gerard's federal trial, Chief Louis Kealoha volunteered from the stand that Puana had a prior arrest, and the judge declared a mistrial. Gerard's lawyer, federal defender Alexander Silvert, took what he had found to federal prosecutors. The case against Gerard was dropped and the FBI opened an investigation. The Kealohas were arrested on Oct. 20, 2017. On June 27, 2019 a jury convicted them and two officers of conspiracy and obstruction, and her bail was revoked the next day. In October 2019 she pleaded guilty to bank fraud, aggravated identity theft and misprision of felony, admitting she stole more than $165,000 from two children whose trust funds she controlled as their guardian. PART FOUR: THE SENTENCE On Nov. 30, 2020, Chief U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright sentenced her to 13 years and $454,984.78 in restitution. Louis Kealoha got 7 years, and two officers got 42 and 54 months. "You framed your uncle for a crime he never committed," the judge told her. She said: "My actions are my own and I truly am sorry for them." Her grandmother's letter to the court said: "You betrayed me." Florence Puana died in February 2020, at 100. PART FIVE: EVERY DOOR SHE TRIED No appeal was ever filed. In 2022 she filed a handwritten motion to be released and asked for bail, citing her health and COVID conditions. Bail was denied on Sept. 9, 2022; the judge wrote that her conduct was "widespread, pervasive, and destructive." Her challenge was denied on May 17, 2023 as filed about six months too late, and permission to appeal was refused. We found no new request from her to any court since: no compassionate release, no sentence reduction, no clemency, in published court rulings or in the news through Nov. 15, 2026. PART SIX: SO WHY IS SHE LEAVING? Federal sentencing credits. Hawaii News Now reports 17 months of credit for time jailed before sentencing, 26 months of good-conduct time and 30 months of First Step Act credits earned through classes and programs. Under the First Step Act, credits can end a sentence up to a year early; the rest moves the remaining time out of prison. The Bureau of Prisons moves her from FCI Victorville to a Bay Area halfway house on Nov. 20, 2026 (Hawaii no longer has a federal halfway house), then to home confinement. She remains a federal prisoner until her release date of July 24, 2029, and supervised release follows. "[She] is simply getting the benefit of those rules that apply to every defendant," retired federal defender Alexander Silvert told KITV. Eric Seitz, lawyer for Gerard Puana and Florence Puana's estate, told KITV: "I'm not optimistic that they have taken responsibility for the harm that they did, particularly to grandma." PART SEVEN: THE BILL Honolulu paid $2.85 million to settle Gerard Puana's lawsuit and $659,566 defending its Ethics Commission from the Kealohas' lawsuit. Louis Kealoha left HPD with a $250,000 payout he agreed to repay if convicted; the city says he still owes it, and he draws a pension of about $150,000 a year. He was released from federal custody on May 18, 2026. The Puana family's lawyer says little of what they are owed has been paid. PART EIGHT: IS THIS FAIR? Her sentence was 13 years. She will have spent about 7 years and 4 months behind bars, 57 percent, and about 10 years in federal custody of any kind. Congress abolished federal parole in 1984 so most of a federal sentence would be served; the First Step Act of 2018, passed 87 to 12 in the Senate and 358 to 36 in the House and co-sponsored by both of Hawaii's senators, added credits for classes and programs. Supporters, including the Fraternal Or...